|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SUBJECT: # 35539: Spinning reel decision????????
Submitted by rb from RHODE ISLAND on 7/21/01 12:21:00 AM
I am going to purchase a spinning reel to go on my new custom built 9' Lamiglas graphite surf rod. Having a tough time deciding! I am one of those who likes to keep the weight of the combo down to lessen fatigue!!!!! Have looked at the following Daiwa BG 20, Penn SS 5500, Shimano Baitrunner 4500. I will be spooling with 30lb power pro. I know the Daiwa SSII are sweet but trying not to spend that much!! The other 3 are within $25 of each other. Any other choices?? Helpful hints and opinions wanted!!!!!!!!
- 7/21/01 2:01:00 AM
Submitted by
Mick Mahi (209.255.109.234) from TEXAS says Move up to the SS-6500 or 7500
30# line is too heavy for the 5500. I would go with the SS 6500 or 7500. They have metal case's and are a little heavier, but they're a lot more rugged than the graphite bodied 5500.
- 7/21/01 9:25:00 AM
Submitted by
rb (165.247.10.242) from RHODE ISLAND says Mick!
The power pro is braid! It is equivalent to 8lb mono.
- 7/21/01 1:14:00 PM
Submitted by
Chris (24.188.65.140) from NEW YORK says 8lb mono vs 30lb braid
rb, it may be the diameter of 8lb mono but does have a line test of 30lb, I believe Mick is suggesting that could be tough on those small reels and I agree.
- 7/21/01 8:54:00 PM
Submitted by
rb (165.247.15.228) from RHODE ISLAND says ??
I am looking for opinions on the quality of the reels in question! I am not worried about whether the reels can handle line with 30lb breaking strength. One of the reasons we now use braid is for line capacity situations. I dont plan on cinching down the drag as if I had 30lb mono on it!! Do you understand where I am coming from??I am looking for a durable reel that doesnt weigh 20 oz like most do!! If weight wasnt a factor I would just go with a Penn 704 and live with it!! I meant a 3500 baitrunner BTW!
- 7/22/01 6:22:00 PM
Submitted by
King's mackeral (24.25.43.35) from NORTH CAROLINA says spinning reel
I'd go with the 5500 or the 6500.... I went thru a lot of reels when I was stuck on shore... since I've switched to the penn ss spinners, I've only had to buy a new one 'cause I threw one in the water...(in 75 ft of water) I'd put them on the rod and try them in the store, yes it'll look silly, but you'll know what fells better and with all the casting you do from shore or pier.... you want the smallest that will tame what your fishin' for... Scott
- 7/23/01 8:45:00 AM
Submitted by
John957 (63.209.180.128) from NEW JERSEY says Daiwa's
I'd do with the daiwa's. I use the original SS2600 with 30lb fireline and never have any problem pulling 25lb stipers against the current.
- 7/23/01 10:32:00 AM
Submitted by
tmk (161.114.88.73) from GEORGIA says Don't buy a Penn 8500
My bride bought me a new Penn 8500 as my birthday present. Fishing it this past week we had a nice Amberjack on. First fish on this reel. About the time I had him about 50' from the boat, all of a sudden, I had a rod & reel in my right hand and a reel handle in my left hand. It had quite simply shattered. I have several Penn's, 320's, one 30T, a 113, and 114,, but from now on, I think I'll just buy something else. Bouncing around in 3 footer's, and hand over handing an Amberjack isn't my idea of fun.
- 7/23/01 1:00:00 PM
Submitted by
John W (24.94.135.74) from FLORIDA says hey tmk...
I've been using Penn SS reels for almost 20 years without a problem from any of them. I have 2 8500's, one is about 15 years old, one is 2 years old, they've handled 130+lb tarpon, kingfish, cobia, etc etc. I think your bad experience with these reels is very unusual, and I'm sure Penn will replace your reel. These reels aren't fancy or exceptionally smooth (or light), but they're as close to bullet proof as I've found. The handle "shattered"? I don't see how that's possible if it was locked properly. Your situation is definitely not the norm with these reels.
- 7/23/01 7:58:00 PM
Submitted by
Summoner (192.152.140.9) from TEXAS says Cranking it like a wench?
Maybe he was cranking it like a wench instead of pumping the rod?
- 7/24/01 8:21:00 AM
Submitted by
Charlie (216.44.69.196) from . says Penn 850
Make sure you keep the side plate screws tighten at all times. I have had mine back out several times. I guess this is caused by the vibration of the diesel powered boats I fish on. We did ruin one set of gears in an 850 with a nice bluefin tuna after the side plate got loose; and the gears did mesh properly.
